@nbache
> Just because the new DiskDoctor can fix disks using the FFS from OS 3.1, doesn't mean it also knows everything about the ones using the newer FFS found in OS 4.x.
Actually, it does
I started working on what would become the new Disk Doctor when it became apparent that AmigaOS 4 would no longer include a diagnostic, recovery and repair tool for the OFS/FFS/DCFS/LNFS file system flavours.
This turned into quite a long research project and when it became just useful enough to test it, it seemed like it would make a good addition to AmigaOS 3.1.4 and ship with it.
The plan is still to make the new Disk Doctor work on AmigaOS4, but first I have to make the repair operation work well. This is what I "cut" from the version which was released for AmigaOS 3.1.4 since I had misjudged the effort required to make the examine and copy/recovery operations work well and usable, too.
> It may be possible, but I would be very careful and make sure I only work on data I can afford to lose.
The new Disk Doctor is for the time being limited to examining volumes for defects and for recovering their contents. No changes are made to the volume, this is a strictly non-invasive tool.
Given the time to finish development on it, and testing, too, of course, it won't be limited to these operations. There will always be a situation in which copying/recovering data from a volume is not the best option available and a repair in place would be preferrable. I intend to deliver that for both AmigaOS 4 and as an update to AmigaOS 3.1.4 when the repair operation is ready for release.